Photo: The Island Packet
A South Carolina judge has rejected Alex Murdaugh's request to dismiss his murder indictments, meaning the disgraced former attorney will still face a retrial over the deaths of his wife and son. The decision was announced on Friday (November 20) by Judge Debra R. McCaslin in Lexington, South Carolina.
The ruling comes after Murdaugh's legal team argued that the grand jury was presented with false and misleading evidence by state investigators. They claimed that former South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) Special Agent David Owen gave inaccurate testimony about blood evidence found on Murdaugh's shirt and about ammunition at the crime scene. Murdaugh's defense alleged that Owen lied to the grand jury.
Prosecutors denied these claims, stating that Owen presented what he believed to be true at the time, which is allowed under state law even if later proven incorrect. The state also maintained that the evidence on the shirt is not false, and their expert stands by it, while gunshot evidence is supported by other findings.
In her written order, Judge McCaslin noted that there were "major errors" in how evidence was presented to the grand jury, but said, "even if the challenged testimony concerning the blood spatter on the T-shirt and shotgun ammunition were excluded from consideration by the Grand Jury, the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause." She concluded that Murdaugh's attorneys "did not establish intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct that compromised the integrity of the grand jury proceedings."
Judge McCaslin also stated that although Owen failed to review a key laboratory report before testifying, the oversight "does not rise to the level of bad faith warranting dismissal of indictments." She added that grand jury proceedings are secret and that no transcript or recording exists to determine the exact substance of the testimony.
The retrial for Murdaugh, who was previously convicted in 2023 before that verdict was overturned by the South Carolina Supreme Court due to jury tampering concerns, is expected to begin on April 5, 2027 in Sumter County.