State Supreme Court To Consider Clancy Appeal

CORRECTION / US-CRIME-HEALTH-CLANCY

Photo: GREG DERR / AFP / Getty Images

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will hear an appeal from Lindsay Clancy's defense team in January 2027, seeking to dismiss murder charges against her. Clancy is accused of strangling her three children in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in 2023, and her defense argues she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time. Her first trial ended in a mistrial in September when the jury could not reach a unanimous verdict.

The appeal focuses on claims that a juror in the first trial refused to follow the law, which the defense argues violated Clancy's right to a fair trial. They contend that the trial court should have conducted a more thorough inquiry into the juror's conduct before declaring a mistrial. The defense also argues that retrying Clancy would violate her double jeopardy rights.

Associate Justice Elizabeth Dewar has referred the appeal to the full court, stating that a review of its merits is warranted. Clancy's brief on the appeal is due by December 3, and the government must respond by December 17. Oral arguments are scheduled for January 2027.

Prosecutors oppose the appeal, arguing that the trial judge, William Sullivan, properly declared a mistrial after the jury reported a deadlock. They assert that further questioning of the holdout juror could have intruded on the jury's deliberations and pressured the juror to change his vote. The prosecution maintains that retrying Clancy does not violate double jeopardy and is necessary to seek justice for the victims.

Clancy's retrial is scheduled to begin on March 29, 2027, with a pretrial conference set for February 18.