Parents Criticize School Photos for Looking Like Mug Shots As Kids Embrace No Smiling Trend

Connecticut Students Return To School With Hybrid Model During COVID-19 Pandemic

Photo: John Moore / Getty Images News / Getty Images

Parents are voicing concerns after receiving school portraits of their children that they say resemble mug shots rather than traditional school photos.

One parent, Whitney Friedericksen, described her reaction to seeing her 10-year-old son Greyden’s portrait, saying it showed "no emotion, no expression." She shared the image with family, asking, "What is this?" according to the Wall Street Journal.

Friedericksen, a stay-at-home mother near Houston, said her son is usually adventurous, funny, and sweet, but he refuses to smile in pictures, which, she noted, does not reflect his real personality. She found the situation amusing, but other parents have expressed frustration, noting that school photos are meant to capture students’ personalities and milestones, not deliver a somber or unflattering image.

The trend has sparked a conversation among families about how these portraits are taken and whether schools or photographers should encourage children to relax and smile during their photo sessions. Some parents have circulated the images among family members and on social media, highlighting the difference between their children's usual expressions and those captured on school picture day.

Despite the trend, parents continue to purchase the photo packages which have gotten more expensive in recent years.

“It’s a story to tell down the road,” Friedericksen said. “When they have their own kids, they’ll have to explain it to them.”

As the debate continues, some families are calling for more flexible approaches to student portraits that better reflect children's true selves.