Photo: Plantation Police Department
A Florida man has been arrested after allegedly mailing a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to a woman he knew had a severe, potentially life-threatening peanut allergy, according to police.
The Plantation Police Department said Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, was taken into custody and faces charges of aggravated battery and culpable negligence. The arrest came more than a year after the woman, a Plantation resident, returned home on August 14, 2025, and discovered an envelope in her mailbox containing a greeting card "smeared with peanut butter." According to police, the woman recognized the substance immediately, dropped the envelope, and washed her hands. She later developed hives, redness, itching, and tingling in her arms that lasted for about six hours.
The probable cause affidavit stated the woman and Cancellare had known each other for over 20 years and were previously friends. Authorities allege Cancellare was well aware of the woman's allergy, which was so severe that even touching or inhaling peanut particles could be dangerous.
Police said the envelope was mailed under a fictitious name, "Goergina Sawals," and included a false return address. Investigators traced the envelope to stamps purchased at a U.S. Postal Service self-service kiosk in Davie, Florida. Surveillance photos and debit card records connected Cancellare to the purchase, officials said. A booking report indicated the stamps' unique code matched Cancellare's transaction, and a post office camera captured images of the buyer.
Police reports also state the woman recognized Cancellare as the ex-husband of her best friend and said he blamed her for his divorce.
Cancellare was arrested at his Plantation home and was held on $20,000 bond. The allegations remain part of an ongoing criminal case. The Plantation Police Department stated, "This case reminds us that actions intended to harm others can have serious, potentially life-threatening consequences," as reported by ABC13.