Photo: GREG DERR / AFP / Getty Images
A Massachusetts judge has denied Lindsay Clancy's motion to dismiss her triple-murder case, paving the way for a retrial. Clancy, who is accused of killing her three children in 2023, had her first trial end in a hung jury. Her defense argued that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the murders.
Judge William Sullivan ruled on Monday (November 9) that a retrial would not violate Clancy's double jeopardy rights, as there was "manifest necessity" for the mistrial due to the jury's deadlock. Sullivan also denied a motion to investigate the holdout juror from the previous trial, stating that further inquiry would intrude on the juror's privacy and discourage future jury service.
According to CNN, the judge rejected the defense's argument that the mistrial was unnecessary and that the juror should have been removed. The defense had claimed that the juror was not following instructions regarding reasonable doubt. However, Sullivan stated that questioning the juror would improperly intrude into the jury's function.
The PBS NewsHour reports that the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office has not yet decided whether to retry Clancy or pursue lesser charges. The next court appearance is scheduled for November 16, when the judge is expected to set a date for the new trial.
Sullivan also denied a prosecution request for a gag order on Clancy's defense team, stating that the prosecution failed to justify the need for such a measure. The judge reminded Clancy's defense of their ethical obligations but noted that public statements made by the defense did not pose a serious threat to jury selection or the outcome of a retrial.